Welcome to Dicarlo's Original Pizza
Dicarlo's Original Pizza, a cherished Wellsburg staple for nearly 60 years, offers a unique twist on traditional pizza with its hallmark hot crust and cold provolone cheese combination. Crafted from fresh daily-made dough and a proprietary signature sauce, each square slice reflects a commitment to quality. Community favorites cite its vibrant flavors and comforting ambiance, perfect for family gatherings or casual takeout. Diners rave about the thick, square slices and inviting atmosphere, where even pets are welcomed. Biting into a slice transports you back to childhood memories, making it clear why Dicarlo's is a timeless favorite in the Ohio Valley.
-
523 Commerce St Wellsburg, WV 26070 United States Hotline: (304) 737-9849
Welcome to Dicarlo's Original Pizza, a beloved gem in the heart of Wellsburg, West Virginia, that has been serving up pizza with a unique twist for nearly 60 years. Nestled at 523 Commerce St, this family-oriented establishment has made its mark as the go-to destination for pizza lovers across the Ohio Valley. Dicarlo's is not just a place to grab a bite; it’s a cornerstone of the community where families, friends, and even our furry companions come together to enjoy delicious food.
What sets Dicarlo’s apart is their distinctive cooking method. Unlike typical pizza places, Dicarlo's boasts a special brick oven that flash-bakes the crust and sauce, creating an irresistible base. Once the fragrant, steaming crust emerges, it is adorned with a generous layer of cold, creamy provolone cheese. This innovative combination of hot crust and cold cheese creates an unforgettable flavor profile that has garnered a devoted following. As customer Heidi B. states, it’s a tradition in many households for occasions big and small, solidifying Dicarlo’s as a family favorite.
Beyond their signature pizza, Dicarlo’s offers a variety of mouth-watering options, including:
- Calzones: Perfectly stuffed, hot out of the oven, and priced at just $2.00 to $6.50.
- Salads: Fresh and vibrant, ranging from a simple garden salad at $2.25 to hearty chef salads loaded with delicious toppings for $5.25.
- Hot Baked Sandwiches: A tasty diversion, with options starting at $5.49.
What’s truly heartwarming is the atmosphere that Dicarlo’s has fostered. With outdoor seating available and a welcoming attitude towards dogs, families can enjoy their meals in a friendly and relaxed environment. Customers have shared glowing reviews, remarking on the unbeatable flavor of the pizza, the attentive service, and the nostalgic connection many have with this local staple. As customer Gary S. reflects, Dicarlo's is always on his list of must-visits whenever he's back in town.
Dicarlo's Original Pizza isn’t just about pizza; it’s about creating memories. With options for delivery, takeout, and catering, they ensure that everyone can enjoy their exceptional food, no matter the occasion. Whether you're gathering for a birthday party, a movie night at home, or just a hungry craving for top-notch pizza, Dicarlo's has you covered.
If you haven't tried their classic DiCarlo’s style pizza yet, you’re in for a treat! Most locals swear by it with the cold cheese on top—a unique experience that elevates traditional pizza to new heights. Dicarlo's stands as a testament to quality, flavor, and community, making it a must-visit spot for anyone in the Wellsburg area. Come on in, grab a slice, and experience the timeless delight that is Dicarlo's Original Pizza!
For inquiries or to place an order, you can reach them at (304) 737-9849. Embrace the pizza that has captured hearts and appetites alike!
They are awesome! Love the pizza! Crust is to die for! The guys welcome our pup every time we go!
I know people that come from states away to get this pizza. It has always been a staple in our family. We have had it on all occasions from birthdays to movie nights and sleepovers with the kids. Dicarlos pizza will always be a favorite in my family.
Great place to order delivery or takeout. Fast service, fair price, and excellent pizza. Not much of a "dine-in" experience, but I don't think the guys would mind if you hang out and shoot the sheet while you have a slice.
I grew up on this pizza and whenever I am back in Wellsburg, I make it a top priority to indulge in this deliciousness. It's always outstanding!
If you like the raw cheese on top your pizza then this is the best hands down!! Talk like a local and Order a Reg Pepperoni and and cheese on top!!
The pizza here is always head and shoulders above any other pizza I have ever had it has yet to disappoint the flavor is one of a kind the service is fast and fair and when I lived out of town it was the reason I came to visit we could not come to wellsburg without stopping at dicarlos
Hometown pizza. Seriously you can't find pizza like this anywhere. Square thick pizza. Delicious sauce. Timeless. I seriously do not believe they have ever changed their recipe after all these years. I'm 41 and I was a baby eating this stuff. Been around for years. An Ohio valley exclusive.
I grew up on DiCarlo's Original Pizza located in Wellsburg, WV, so I am quite familiar with the taste and quality associated with DiCarlo's. From their website they provide the following information: For nearly 60 years, DiCarlo's very unique combination of hot crust - cold cheese has been successfully satisfying their devoted customers.Only DiCarlo's initially flash-bakes its crust and sauce in a special brick oven, and when the steaming crust emerges, it is adorned with cold creamy provolone cheese, making the taste indescribable! Orginal DiCarlo's Pizza uses NO frozen products. Fresh dough mixed daily in all of our stores. Our very own signature sauce made from superior-tasting, fresh tomatoes and combined with our unique spice mixture. We pride ourselves in using only the finest quality 100% provolone cheese, never pre-shredded. Only 100% meats - no fillers. We use products free of MSG. I can assure you that this pizza is quality and delicious. It is pizza served either by the slice at 90 cents per slice, or you can opt for a boxed square which usually will run you around 13.99 for a box of 16 slices. You can only order takeout at this location. Their pizza is good enough to take home and enjoy! If you get it "DiCarlo's style", it is with cold cheese on top. I prefer it this way, but to each their own. This is their signature style and it really adds to the flavor. They will happily melt the cheese for those of you that request it that way. I give it 2 thumbs way up! Great pizza!